I sat down to work, but paused to read a food review in Isthmus by Linda Falkenstein of Mad Dog's Chicago Style Eatery. We had finished dinner an hour ago, but this was too good to pass up.
I headed over to State and Henry and marched in with a chip on my shoulder. These guys were in serious trouble.
I am an expert on Chicago hot dogs. I could claim to be the expert but prefer to avoid a confrontation with my siblings and cousins, all less experienced but who claim to be bon vivants.
I know my hot dogs; I have eaten them for almost sixty years. I ate them on the south side, west side, and north sides of Chicago. I ate them in the suburbs and in the ball parks. (No Chicago ball park ever served a real Chicago hot dog.) I ate them at Fluky's, Stash's, Big Herm's (he had only one good arm), Little Herm's (two good arms), a dozen places on Dempster or off of Western, more on Damen*, and all over Stoney Island. (The best was next to the Avalon Theater.) And I have a heart by-pass to prove it.
If you are over the age of ten, there are only two ways to order a Chicago Hot Dog - with "everything" (also "the works") or "everything but peppers." There are guys sleeping with the fishes in Lake Michigan who uttered the word catsup.
I watched the young woman take out the bun and carefully build my hot dog. Immediately I suspected there was something wrong. Missing was the the grizzled knuckles, hairy arms, the sweat dripping off her just as hairy brow, topped by a paper hat that looked like it been used to clean her shoes. How novel; a Chicago hot dog prepared by someone who could get by the health inspector.
She wrapped my dream and I headed out the door.
I bit in, prepared for mustard to ooze from the side of my lips and a few pieces of relish and onions to fall on to my shirt. It did. They did.
The bun: too few poppy seeds but nicely steamed. Not too moist, not too dry.
The hot dog. A tasty Vienna Beef that needed to be a bit warmer. Certainly superior to the imitations.
Onions - properly sliced and chopped, flavorful but still leaving me kissable.
Tomatoes - ripe and fitting neatly in the package.
Pickle spear - and that is what it was. It crunched very nicely but was not the classic new pickle or 'cuke.'
Celery salt - dashed appropriate for size of the hot dog and bun.
Day-glow green relish - proper color, stayed in its place and did not overwhelm the hot dog.
Hot peppers - I passed. After all, this was my second dinner.
My concern that a well kempt woman could not properly prepare the hot dog was not warranted; it was more than acceptable.
I give it a grade of B-. Now that is a hot dog worth eating, considering that 90% of the spindly wieners served as a Chicago Hot Dog would get a C or lower.
As for Falkenstein's review, she should be banned from sampling any important culinary delight. Her lead is, "It's hard to get too persnickety about a food that's usually sold out of stainless steel street carts or hawked from boxes at ballgames.."
Too persnickety? Too persnickety? I'll show you persnickety.
The woman has screwed up priorities. Send her to the french cafes, the brat festivals, the pricey coffee houses, quiche and wine parties, and the upscale 'chop' houses. She has no respect for quality food and she has no business eating hot dogs, let alone reviewing them.
*opps. Thanks Steve.