Ex-Alder Brenda Konkel is a glutton for punishment. She attends, and often blogs (at This Side of Town/Forward Lookout), more local government meetings than are healthy for anyone. She's stepped up her game recently and become a multi-media mogul, with regular shows on WORT radio and WYOU public access cable TV. The public interest and the public's awareness both benefit from Brenda's obsessive participation in local affairs.
Recently she's been on a mission to create an attendance score for Madison City alders. The result, a work in progress that Brenda admits is based on flawed and incomplete information, is actually kind of reassuring. In a post titled: "Is Your Alder Doing Their Job?" Brenda provides a preliminary list of Madison alders and their ratio of committee meetings attended:
33% Thuy Pham-Remmele 1/3
38% Brian Solomon 5/13
47% Jed Sanborn 17/36
66% Michael Schumacher 33/50
68% Bridget Maniaci 13/19
72% Joe Claussius 36/50
75% Lauren Cnare 25/33
81% Julia Kerr 13/16
81% Larry Palm 13/16
87% Mike Verveer 36/41
87% Satya Rhodes-Conway 34/39
87% Judy Compton 21/24
88% Mark Clear 38/43
88% Paul Skidmore 23/26
92% Tim Bruer 38/41
95% Chris Schmidt 23/24
96% Shiva Bidar Sielaff 24/25
96% Marsha Rummel 24/25
100% Steve King 7/7
100% Bryon Eagon 26/26
As a career professor, I can't help seeing the numbers in terms of semester grade averages. It's a pretty typical grade distribution for a mid-level undergraduate class. I see 5 alders with clear A+ grades, 6 with A's or very high B+ grades, 2 with B's, 2 got C's, 2 just managed D's, and 3 clearly flunked with F's. So out of a class of 20, there's three students alders (Pham-Remmele, Solomon, and Sanborn) that either don't belong there at all and have been totally missing in action. Two others (Schumacher and Maniaci) need to party far less and study more, or find a less demanding major.
Too bad this is real important city business and the five slackers are wasting taxpayer dollars, not their own tuition. But on the positive side, 75% of the alders are attending over 70% of their meetings, and 65% are attending over 80%.
Brenda's not done factoring in as many meetings as possible, so there's possible improvements before the grades become final. All whining for extra credit should be directed to Ms. Konkel.
- Barry Orton