Today the University of Wisconsin Union Theater will host Ayaan Hirsi Ali as part of the Distinguished Lecture Series.
Originally she was rejected as a speaker -too controversial.
UW to host controversial author who rejects Islam
Students first voted against bringing Hirsi Ali because they didn't want to be seen as supporting her agenda, said Reid Tice, chair of the Distinguished Lecture Series committee. But when a scheduled speaker, sportswriter Rick Reilly, fell through, the committee reconsidered Hirsi Ali...
Hirsi Ali wrote the screenplay for "Submission," a short movie by Dutch filmmaker Theo van Gogh that criticized the treatment of women in Islamic society. In 2004, an extremist killed van Gogh in Amsterdam and left a death threat against Hirsi Ali pinned to his chest with a knife.
Hirsi Ali said she will focus her speech on the plight of women in Islam and the importance of talking about it, even though it can be risky.
It is sad and even frightening that students, or any one for that matter, would succumb to the notion that the right to speak is measured by the messenger being timid, meek, and boring.
Fortunately there was an opportunity to revisit the issue and the right thing was done.
As a student I had the privilege to hear Hubert Humphrey and George Wallace, Joan Baez and Strom Thurmond, Eldridge Cleaver and Averell Harriman. The campus and the university community was served well by every one of them speaking and sharing their beliefs and thoughts, no matter how controversial, outdated, narrow-minded, or enlightening their speech.
On a sadder note, Isthmus reports that the city of Madison Parks Division instituted rules banning the staff speaking to journalists, council members or just about any one, A 'gag rule' at city parks
As Isthmus has reported (Watchdog, 1/22/09), Parks Superintendent Kevin Briski, upon taking over in June 2008, began requiring that all media inquiries be routed through Whitmore. He thinks this policy has worked out well: "It's helped facilitate efficient communication."
But clearly the new policy has struck fear in the hearts of some Parks employees. One person even asked not to be quoted saying s/he could not be quoted.
A few words of advice. No one is served well by limiting the speech of city staff. In fourteen years as mayor, our office had a very simple policy - make sure you know what you are talking about, and if you are unsure refer the matter to someone who does.
That was it. No gag rule. No lengthy talking points. I do not recall any disasters. There were a few embarrassing moments when a staff member said something and did not have all the information but nothing that would remotely justify a gag order.
As the President of the Madison Parks Commission, Bill Barker noted:
"The tradition of the city has always been transparency and open government. Anything that runs counter to that is not a good idea."
City council members are a different story but, not to worry, no one will ever keep them quiet.